Pie of the Tiger Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Pie of the Tiger, a standout establishment in Columbus, OH, redefining pizza with bold flavors and a unique approach. This culinary gem offers a delightful menu that emphasizes customization and variety. The hallmark of their selection is the Build Your Own Tiger Pizza, where guests can craft an 8" square pie with their choice of toppings and sauces, ensuring every bite is tailored to individual tastes.
- Bar Snacks: Start your meal with enticing options like Bone-In Chicken Wings or Garlic Parmesan Tiger Balls, perfect for sharing.
- Between Bread: Sink your teeth into hearty subs, such as the flavorful Italian Sub or the comforting Meatball Sub.
- Signature Pizzas: Try innovative flavors like the Dill Thrill or the meaty The Big Cat.
The atmosphere is vibrant, complemented by efficient delivery and takeout options, making it an ideal spot for any pizza lover. Experience the roaring flavors at Pie of the Tiger!
Bar Snacks
Bone-In Chicken Wings
Boneless Chicken Wings
Fried Mushrooms
Jalapeno Poppers
Mozzarella Sticks
Pickle Fries
Pizza House Cheese Bread
Split Auddino's roll toasted with garlic butter, minced garlic, provolone & Italian seasoning. Comes with a side of red sauce.
Sample Basket
Mozzarella sticks, fried mushrooms, jalapeno poppers & pickle fries with red sauce, ranch & Tiger sauce on the side.
Tater Wedges
Garlic Parmesan Tiger Balls
Fried dough balls tossed in garlic sauce, parmesan cheese & Italian seasoning with red sauce, ranch & Tiger sauce.
Italian Sub
Jumbo pepperoni, genoa salami, ham, capicola and provolone on a toasted hoagie with tomato, red onions, romaine and banana peppers tossed in creamy Italian dressing.
Meatball Sub
House meatballs. garlic butter, red sauce, provolone and shaved parmesan on a toasted hoagie roll.
Between Bread
Tiger Pizza
Build Your Own
8" square pizza cut into 4 pieces. All pizzas come with provolone unless you specify otherwise. Choose your toppings and sauce.
Half & Half
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Provolone, chicken, red onions & bacon with BBQ sauce - no red sauce.
BCR
Provolone, chicken & bacon with ranch on top - no red sauce.
Chicken Parmesan
Garlic butter, minced garlic, provolone, roasted chicken, Italian seasoning, red sauce & shaved parmesan.
Dill Thrill
Minced garlic, garlic butter, provolone & dill pickles with ranch & Old Bay hot sauce on top - no red sauce. Add bacon +1.50
Just Cheese Please
Garlic Butter, minced garlic, provolone, feta, ricotta & Italian seasoning with red sauce.
Just Pepperoni
Provolone & jumbo pepperoni with red sauce on top.
Margherita
Garlic butter, minced garlic, provolone, tomatoes and ricotta with pesto on top - no red sauce.
Meatball Sundae
Provolone, spicy house meatballs, shaved parmesan, red sauce, ricotta & Italian Seasoning.
The Big Cat
Provolone, jumbo pepperoni, sausage, roasted mushrooms, green peppers, and black olives with red sauce on top
The Italian Job
Genoa salami, capicola, jumbo pepperoni, ham, banana peppers and tomatoes with provolone, shaved parmesan and Italian dressing no red sauce.
Tiny Panther
Provolone, cheddar, Italian sausage, ham & bacon with yellow mustard on top - no red sauce.
Chocolate Strawberry Tiger Balls
Fried dough balls rolled in powdered sugar & topped with chocolate sauce - side of strawberry coulis.